Your Teen Can Disagree With You AND Still Respect You
Updated: Sep 11
Your middle schooler looks at you and says, “I don’t agree with you.”
And something in you immediately goes, Excuse me?
Because sometimes we aren’t actually responding to disrespect. We’re responding to the fact that this child we have kept alive since birth suddenly has the audacity, the unmitigated gall to have a different opinion.
The funny part is, that’s exactly what we’re raising them to do. We want our children to think independently, advocate for themselves, develop their own values, and use their voices. Then the moment they use that voice with us, we’re thinking, Wait a minute. Who are you talking to?
That’s where we have to be careful, because agreement, respect, and authority can quickly get tangled together and they are not the same thing.
Disagreement Is Part of Growing Up
Adolescence brings greater independence, stronger preferences, and more developed opinions. Your middle schooler is becoming a person who has thoughts about what happens to them and increasingly wants to express those thoughts.
Meanwhile, you’re thinking, That’s wonderful. I’m still responsible for raising you.
Both can be true.
Your child can have a perspective without having the final authority. They can think your phone rule is ridiculous, and the phone rule can remain. They can dislike bedtime, and bedtime can remain. They can disagree with your decision and still be expected to follow it.
So before you automatically label disagreement as disrespect, I want you to give the interaction a little SPACE.
S-Statement: What Did They Actually Say?
Start with the words that actually came out of your child’s mouth not what you think they meant underneath them.
“I don’t agree.”
“I think that’s unfair.”
“I wish you would reconsider.”
Those statements may not be what you wanted to hear, but they aren’t automatically disrespectful.
This one hits home for me because my husband and I are military brats, and our household has always been pretty formal: yes ma’am, no ma’am, yes sir, no sir. Don’t hit me with a “cool.”
As our oldest got older and developed stronger opinions of his own, I had to learn to hear what he actually said instead of immediately reacting because it wasn’t the response I wanted.
P- Presentation: How Did They Say It?
Now, we are not swinging so far in the other direction that children get to communicate with us any kind of way in the name of “expressing themselves.” Absolutely not.
The words might communicate disagreement while the presentation crosses a line. Name-calling, mocking, yelling, threatening, disrespectful gestures, or communication that violates your family’s established expectations can absolutely require correction.
That distinction lets you say, “I understand that you disagree with me, but you will not speak to me that way.”
Now you’re addressing the actual behavior instead of punishing your child simply for having an opinion.
And if yelling and arguing have historically become normal in your house, you may need to reset those expectations. In our family, weekly sit-downs with our children have given us a place to establish expectations before we’re in the heat of a conflict.
A- Authority: Who Is Responsible for the Decision?
This is where some parents get nervous. If I let my child disagree, are they going to think we’re equals?
No. Listening isn’t surrendering your authority. Your child can explain their perspective. You can understand it. You can even empathize with their disappointment.
And the answer can still be no.
I used to tell my oldest when he brought up what somebody else was allowed to do, “Such-and-such doesn’t live in this house.” I’m not their mama. I’m yours. Our expectations still stand.
Pausing long enough to hear your child does not diminish your authority.
C- Compliance: Did They Actually Refuse?
This one can save us from a whole unnecessary argument. Your child says, “That’s not fair!”
Then they go upstairs and do exactly what you told them to do. Friend, you have compliance. They’re just unhappy about it.
Sometimes we escalate because we’re trying to force agreement when our child was already prepared to comply. Disagreeing and refusing are two different behaviors.
Give them enough SPACE to show you which one is happening.
E- Expectation: What Do You Actually Need?
Finally, ask yourself what you actually need from your child in that moment. Do you need them to follow the direction? Respect the boundary? Communicate appropriately?
Or do you need them to agree that you’re right? Whew.
Our job is to provide structure, hold appropriate boundaries, make responsible decisions, and teach our children how to communicate. It is not our job to control every opinion they develop.
Maybe the expectation is simply:
You’re allowed to disagree. You’re expected to communicate appropriately. And you still have to do the thing.
That is parenting without confusing authority with control.
Give the Interaction a Little SPACE
The next time disagreement starts feeling like disrespect, pause before going from zero to sixty.
Consider the Statement. Presentation. Authority. Compliance. Expectation.
You may discover that something truly does need correcting. But you may also discover that your child simply disagreed with you and you didn’t like it.
Our middle schoolers didn’t come with manuals. Now they have opinions, mouths, and increasingly independent minds to go along with them. Our job isn’t to silence those voices. It’s to teach our children how to use them appropriately.
Before you label disagreement as disrespect, give the interaction a little SPACE.
The SPACE Cheat Sheet, companion resource to Episode 3 of Middle School Mayhem™, is available in the Parent Vault to help you walk through the framework with a real interaction.
Comments